Brexit hit us too: Jersey fishermen react to French protest

a small boat in a body of water: French fishing boats protested in midweek off Jersey's main port of Saint Helier over what they see as unfair post-Brexit restrictions © Sameer Al-DOUMY French fishing boats protested in midweek off Jersey's main port of Saint Helier over what they see as unfair post-Brexit restrictions

"If it goes on like this, there won't be any more fishing around here," warns Loic Farnham, a 30-year-old fisherman, after post-Brexit rule changes prompted a furious French protest.

Jersey's picturesque main port of Saint Helier on Thursday saw French fishermen stage an angry protest over the new system of allocating fishing rights.

A flotilla of boats sailed over at dawn and threatening to blockade the harbour. The standoff briefly escalated, with Britain sending over gunboats.

Fishermen based in Jersey varied in how harshly they viewed the French direct action.

But they agreed that the post-Brexit deal hit their fragile livelihoods and relations with nearby France.

"If we'd have gone across to a port in France I hate to think what would have happened to our boats," said 69-year-old Richard Lebrun, who has been a fisherman for 40 years, in defence of the UK's reaction.

a small boat in a large body of water: Britain responded to the French protest by sending in patrol boats -- in the distance the British navy's HMS Tamar is watched by a French fishing boat off Jersey © Sameer Al-DOUMY Britain responded to the French protest by sending in patrol boats -- in the distance the British navy's HMS Tamar is watched by a French fishing boat off Jersey

"Let's be honest, you're rather well known for kicking off and firing petrol bombs," he told a French AFP reporter.

The French fishermen protested over an abrupt change in rules on licences to fish in Jersey's waters.

Until the post-Brexit deal, the rules for French boats had been fixed under an agreement called the Granville Bay Treaty signed in 2000 between Jersey and France.

a group of people on a boat: The post-Brexit agreement signed allows French fishermen to ply a zone of British offshore waters, rich in fish and less stormy, but they must prove they had done this in the recent past © Sameer Al-DOUMY The post-Brexit agreement signed allows French fishermen to ply a zone of British offshore waters, rich in fish and less stormy, but they must prove they had done this in the recent past

"It was never right, anyway because the French were giving the French fishermen permits to fish in Jersey waters," Lebrun said, blaming this on Jersey's "weak politicians".

"They had carte blanche to fish there since that time. And now because of Brexit it's changed," he said.

"We are supposed to have the right to say who does and who doesn't fish in our waters."

The post-Brexit agreement signed in late December by London and Brussels allows French fishermen to ply a zone of the British offshore waters, which are rich in fish and less stormy, as long as they could prove they had done this in the recent past.

This zone includes waters off the Channel Islands, which belong to the Crown but are self-governing and not part of the United Kingdom and therefore did not even vote in the Brexit referendum.

For 60-year-old local fisherman Wayne Lowe, the problematic factor is the large size of the French fishing fleet

"The ones that have fished with us for years would be OK, there's got to be a cap on the fleet somewhere," he said.

- 'Separate deal'-

During the protest, some local residents from Gouray, a village in Jersey's southeast came to meet the French. 

Acting as a mediator was Chris Le Masurier, an oyster farmer and owner of a boat used for freight, the Normandy Trader.

"What may work between France and Britain won't work here," with the Normandy coast around 20 kilometres (12 miles) away, he insists.

"There absolutely must be a separate agreement."

"We need access to the European market to sell our goods," he added.

Due to the recent tensions, Jersey's fishermen have been warned not to take their catch to Normandy's ports "for two days". This has now been tightened into an outright ban punishable with arrest.

"Without the French market, we have nothing," said Farnham.

The father-of-two stressed how close the French fishing ports are from here.

As soon as the boats "leave the port, they're over here" in Jersey's waters, he said.

"The way I see it, they have as much right as us to fish here."

- "No London or Brussels' -

Farnham began fishing a year ago in an 11.5 metre coastal fishing boat but his livelihood has been hit since by the coronavirus restrictions and the current tensions with France.

Since mid-December, Farnham has only made six trips to sell to individual customers, he said, and he has to work on construction sites.

In another consequence of Brexit, the catch of a Jersey-based boat that unloads in France has to comply with stricter sanitary standards than the catch of a French boat.

"Their shells were harvested in ideal waters but mine weren't," said Farnham.

"It's ridiculous!"

To resolve the issue he is trying to organise local talks, "so that they leave us to negotiate our deal with France together, without London, without Brussels.

Fishing is "a great job. The sea is wonderful," he said.

But at the same time he warned: "If this doesn't change in the next few months, I won't have any choice: I'll have to sell my boat."

spe/am/cdw

Brexit hit us too: Jersey fishermen react to French protest